
Notary Signing Agents (NSAs) play a critical role in real estate transactions, ensuring loan documents are properly executed, notarized, and returned on time. However, gaining the trust of title companies takes more than just having a commission and training—it takes professionalism, reliability, and integrity. One misstep can lead to being blacklisted, effectively cutting off a valuable stream of business.
In this blog post, we’ll explore the top reasons NSAs get blacklisted by title companies and how you can protect your reputation and secure long-term success.
1. Late or Missing Documents
One of the most common—and damaging—offenses is failing to return documents on time or losing them altogether. Loan closings are time-sensitive, and delays can impact funding and create legal headaches.
Avoid it:
- Communicate delays before they become an issue.
- Always ship documents the same day, if possible.
- Use trackable overnight shipping services.
2. Errors in Notarization
Missed signatures, incorrect acknowledgments, or incomplete notarizations can derail an entire transaction.
Avoid it:
- Attend training to sharpen your skills.
- Triple-check every document before leaving the appointment.
- Stay up to date on your state’s notary laws.
3. Unprofessional Behavior
Rude conduct, inappropriate attire, or poor communication with signers or title company staff reflects poorly on everyone involved.
Avoid it:
- Keep personal opinions and distractions out of the appointment.
- Dress business casual or according to the company’s standards.
- Be patient and respectful with clients, even during stressful signings.
4. Breaching Confidentiality
Real estate transactions involve sensitive financial information. Sharing or mishandling that data can result in serious consequences.
Avoid it:
- Understand and follow GLBA (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act) compliance.
- Never discuss signers’ personal details with anyone not authorized.
- Store or dispose of non-returned documents securely.
5. No-Show or Last-Minute Cancellations
Failing to show up—or backing out with little notice—can ruin a signing and the company’s trust in you.
Avoid it:
- Have a network of backup notaries you can refer.
- Accept appointments only when you’re confident in your availability.
- Communicate early if an emergency arises.
6. Lack of Communication
Ghosting the title company after a signing or failing to report issues promptly can lead to blacklisting.
Avoid it:
- Follow up with tracking numbers and delivery confirmation.
- Send confirmation texts or emails upon arrival and completion.
- Immediately alert the company to issues with IDs, documents, or borrower concerns.
7. Overpromising and Underdelivering
Taking on more than you can handle or saying “yes” to unfamiliar documents without proper training can lead to mistakes.
Avoid it:
- Decline assignments outside your expertise until you’re prepared.
- Be honest about your experience and availability.
- Invest in ongoing training and certification.
Title companies need NSAs they can count on—professionals who are timely, accurate, and trustworthy. Getting blacklisted isn’t just about one mistake; it’s usually the result of repeated issues or a serious breach of trust. By following best practices and treating every signing with care, you’ll not only avoid the blacklist—you’ll become a preferred partner.
Want to stay off the blacklist?
Take control of your notary business with proper training, communication, and professionalism. Your reputation is your most valuable asset—protect it.
Daniel C. Lewis resides in Carmel, IN. He was named in 2010 Notary of the Year by the National Notary Association. He was also named in the same year an Honorary Secretary of State by the Indiana Secretary of State. Daniel is currently serving as the Executive Director of the Lewis Notary & Training Services Inc. Daniel is an entrepreneur, writer, video editor, and Keynote Speaker.
Other blogs by this author….
- Mastering Anti-Money Laundering Online Training for Notary Entrepreneurs
- What should Notary Entrepreneurs do in the First Quarter of the Year
- Becoming Successful in Business: The Mindset, Habits, and Strategies That Matter Most
- What to Look for When Choosing a Notary Coach or Notary Mentor
- The Top 5 Risks for Notaries in Handling Sovereign Citizen Documents













